Skip to content

Cart

Your cart is empty

Article: Sterling Silver vs Stainless Steel Jewelry: Which is Better?

Four men’s silver pendants laid on a wooden surface, including two cross designs and two compass designs, each suspended from sterling silver chains. The lighting highlights the polished finish and rugged detail of each piece.

Sterling Silver vs Stainless Steel Jewelry: Which is Better?

Ah, the Stainless Steel vs Sterling Silver jewelry debate. It’s kind of like Batman vs Superman. Everyone has a favourite, but do you really have to choose? The truth is, it’s not about picking sides. You don’t have to wear one and ignore the other. In fact, having both in your collection is essential. It’s more about knowing when, where, and how to wear them.

Man wearing layered sterling silver chains with compass and wing pendants, styled over a black T-shirt and varsity jacket. His look is finished with a bold stack of silver and black rings, spotlighting sterling silver as the core metal in his jewellery collection.

Think of it like this. You wouldn’t throw on your best t-shirt to paint the house. Or wear your fresh white shoes on a muddy walk. (Although let’s be honest, we’ve all done it, and regretted it afterwards.) Jewelry is the same. The right pieces fit the right moment. It’s not always obvious, but we’re here to talk you through it. 

Tap below to find out:

The Difference Between Sterling Silver and Stainless Steel Jewelry

Both of these metals are CRAFTD to last, just in different ways.

Stainless Steel: A tough, ultra-durable alloy, stainless steel is made to take a beating. Finished in real silver or gold, it stays looking new no matter what you put it through. It’s strong, resilient, and hides its age well.

Sterling Silver: 925 Sterling Silver is a precious metal made from 92.5% pure silver. It’s a little softer, a little wiser. It shows its age over time, and that’s the point. It darkens, marks, and develops a look that’s completely yours.

Both are part of the same story. Both belong in your collection. Here's how to figure out what fits where.

The Benefits of Sterling Silver Jewelry

Sterling silver is a little more exclusive than your average piece. Here’s why:

Left: Man wearing a 4mm 925 Sterling Silver Cuban Link Chain over a black T-shirt, showcasing its clean, minimal fit. Right: Close-up of the same chain’s high-polish links and lobster clasp stamped with the 925 hallmark.

Sterling Silver Makes More Detailed Jewelry

925 Sterling Silver has a naturally soft, workable structure. This characteristic not only ensures unmatched comfort against the skin but also allows for the creation of more detailed, eye-catching, and sharply designed pieces of jewellery.

Side-by-side comparison of a 6mm 925 Sterling Silver Cuban Link Chain (left) and an 8mm 316L Stainless Steel Cuban Link Chain (right), highlighting the brighter tone and finer detailing of the sterling silver finish.

Displayed Left: This premium Cuban Link Chain is handmade using traditional techniques and CRAFTD from solid 925 sterling silver, ensuring sharper, cleaner-cut Cuban Links and a high-polish finish.

Sterling Silver Develops a Beautiful Patina 

Strength can be a double-edged sword. Sterling Silver’s softer, more pliable nature is part of what gives it that premium feel. But it also means it’s more reactive to the elements. Water, air, and even the natural oils on your skin can cause it to fade or tarnish over time.

A man leans into a car window wearing a Sterling Silver band and a black stone ring, while on the adjacent image, multiple Sterling Silver Cuban Chains hang from a rearview mirror, catching natural sunlight.

For some, that might sound like a downside. But for others, it’s exactly what makes Sterling Silver so special. The more you wear it, the more it develops its own patina and character. Those subtle changes aren’t flaws, they’re part of your story. Every mark and shift in tone becomes a reflection of where you’ve been and everything your piece has seen along the way.

A couple leans in close, sharing an intimate moment in soft sunlight. The man wears layered 925 Sterling Silver chains over a white tee, with shadows highlighting the polished detail of the jewellery.

Sterling Silver Gets Better With Age

Far from being a flaw, the well worn look of Sterling Silver adds real character to your collection. What some might see as vulnerability is actually what gives it so much value.

Think of it as you would an analogue or film picture. Yes, it may have a bit of grain, but that's the raw, unfiltered beauty that comes with a film image. With that grain also comes a vibrancy of colour that cannot be replicated. 

A couple sit in the front seat of a car, sharing a moment of laughter. The man wears layered 925 Sterling Silver chains and rings, catching the light against his white T-shirt, while the woman smiles, holding a cassette tape toward him.

Sterling Silver is the same. What might look like a minor flaw on the surface reveals a deeper strength. A piece that’s lived a little, and carries that story only you can tell. Tarnish can be polished away in seconds, but those subtle marks and textures will always remain.

A close-up of a man's hand resting on a car door mirror, wearing bold square-set rings with black inlay, crafted from solid 925 Sterling Silver. A tattoo is visible on his forearm, adding a personal touch to the rugged styling.

That’s where the beauty lies. Not in perfection, but in the way it wears over time. So go easy on the polishing cloth. Let it age. Let it tell your story.

Who is Sterling Silver Jewelry For?

It’s these qualities that make Sterling Silver such an authentic or romantic choice for any man. It carries a timeless feel that works at any age. Just as meaningful for a 16 year old as it is for someone at 65.

Pair 925 Sterling Silver with a clean minimal band ring or a classic Cuban Chain, and you’ve got a gift that feels personal, considered, and genuinely desirable. The kind of piece every man wants to wear.

A man’s hand grips a steering wheel while wearing a 925 Sterling Silver Band Ring with a 6mm width. The close-up highlights its polished, minimal design. On the right, the same ring is shown in detail against a neutral background, revealing the inner 'CRAFTD 925' hallmark.

When and Where to Wear Sterling Silver

Think of it like your best shirt. Perfect for weddings, date nights, or any moment where you want to feel on point. It might not be the most practical for the gym or the beach, but when it’s styled right, it always gets noticed.

That said, rules are made to be broken. If you want to wear it every day, do it. Just make sure you know how to keep it looking sharp. A few simple tips are all you need.

A man leans against a vintage car while wearing a white T-shirt and a 925 Sterling Silver Cuban Chain. The close-up highlights the cool-toned polish and textured links of the silver chain as it rests naturally around his neck.
Close-up shot of a man adjusting a 925 Sterling Silver ring on his finger, paired with another silver band and a bold signet ring. On the right, a detailed view of a sterling silver chain and clasp captures the polished finish and intricate design.

The Benefits of Stainless Steel Jewelry

316L Stainless Steel has changed the game for men’s jewelry. It’s shifted the way a lot of people think about everyday pieces and what they should be able to handle.

If you’re after something that looks good, holds up, and gives you serious value for money, Stainless Steel just makes sense. You get the style and strength without any of the usual trade offs with precious metals like solid gold or silver.

Man styled in layered silver-toned stainless steel jewellery, including a pendant necklace, chunky rings, and a cuff bracelet, all paired with a denim jacket and white T-shirt. A close-up highlights the texture and shine of the statement rings and chains, showcasing the bold finish of stainless steel

Stainless Steel Jewelry is More Affordable

This is the kind of jewelry that looks and feels premium without the heavy price tag. Sterling Silver and solid gold will always have their place, but stainless steel brings something different. The quality is so good, most people wouldn’t know it’s not the real deal.

Close-up of layered men's necklaces featuring a saint Christopher pendant in silver-tone metal, a stainless steel chain, and a string of pearls. Styled over a white tee and denim jacket, the layered look blends rugged and refined elements with standout silver detailing.

Stainless Steel Jewelry is More Durable

It’s resistant to water, scratches, and fading, and often finished in real silver or gold for that extra touch. With stainless steel, you get the look, the weight, and the presence of high-end jewelry, minus the guilt. It’s the easiest way to build your collection and switch up your style whenever you feel like it.

Who is Stainless Steel Jewelry For?

Stainless steel jewelry just suits a certain kind of guy. Someone who wants to wear good pieces every day, not just for special occasions.

Side-by-side image showing a man wearing a matching iced tennis chain, bracelet, and cross pendant made from 316L stainless steel, styled with a black tee in natural sunlight. On the right, a football player in a red MONARCHS kit stands on the field under stadium lights.

Maybe he’s in Sterling Silver at dinner with his partner, then hitting the gym later that same day. He needs something that looks good but can handle whatever the day throws at him. That’s where stainless steps in. It’s durable, low-maintenance, and made to keep up without needing any extra thought.

When and Where to Wear Stainless Steel Jewelry

316L Stainless Steel is made for guys who don’t slow down. It’s the go-to for anyone who wants that clean, premium look without worrying about scratches, fading, or taking it off when life gets busy.

Three-panel image featuring a man wearing the North Star Pendant in 316L stainless steel. Left: underwater shot of him surfing beneath a crashing wave. Middle: kneeling on a rocky beach, fitting fins onto a surfboard. Right: close-up of his back showing the pendant resting between his shoulder blades.

Think of it as the most reliable piece in your jewelry rotation. Whether you’re out on a hike or in the middle of the ocean, it’s built to keep up. You don’t settle for ordinary in anything else, your jewellery should be no different.

Close-up of a tattooed hand wearing multiple 18K gold-finished rings made from 316L stainless steel, paired with a fine gold chain bracelet. The rings feature detailed engravings and textures, catching the light with a bold, polished finish.

And here’s the bonus. When you buy from the right brand, your stainless steel pieces are covered for life. Not that you’ll need it. CRAFTD offers lifetime protection on every piece, from stainless steel to Sterling Silver, so you can build your collection without second guessing a thing. 

Close-up of a man's hands and chest showcasing an array of silver-toned rings and layered pendants. The rings feature bold, masculine designs with intricate detailing, while the pendants hang from heavyweight silver chains. Though made from 316L stainless steel, the finish mirrors the timeless appeal of sterling silver.

Which Metal is Best for You?

Both Stainless Steel and Sterling Silver deserve a place in your collection.

925 Sterling Silver is for the guy who pays attention to detail, values the real stuff, and wants pieces that make a statement without trying too hard. Stainless Steel, on the other hand, is built for everyday life. It’s low-maintenance, tough, and always ready to go.

A solid collection has room for both. One brings depth and detail, the other brings confidence and consistency. The sweet spot is knowing when to wear each and letting them work together.

More Jewelry Essentials From CRAFTD:

Close-up of a man wearing two iced-out silver-toned chains layered over a white T-shirt. The high-shine finish and faceted edges give the stainless steel chains a bright, crisp appearance, echoing the timeless aesthetic of sterling silver with added brilliance
Close-up of a man wearing layered silver-toned chains over a black T-shirt and leather jacket. The standout feature is a sterling silver-look angel pendant, intricately detailed and paired with a classic Cuban link chain for bold contrast and timeless shine.
Close-up of tattooed hands styled with stacked silver rings and bracelets, paired with a detailed crucifix pendant worn on layered chains. The jewelry, crafted from 316 stainless steel, stands out against a dark denim jacket and black shirt, offering a bold and expressive statement
Man wearing a black jacket and layered gold compass pendants finished in 18K gold. The North Star-inspired pendants sit on fine gold chains and stand out against the dark outfit, capturing a bold yet refined look.

For more inside info around 925 Sterling Silver, check out these other popular collections and articles:

Leave a comment

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

All comments are moderated before being published.

Read more

Man in white t-shirt wearing a Sterling Silver Cuban Link Chain

Why every man should own a Sterling Silver Cuban Chain

Sterling Silver carries your story. As you wear it, it naturally picks up subtle patinas and textures that reflect the life you’ve lived in it. No two pieces age the same, and that’s the beauty of ...

Read more
Sterling Silver Cuban Link Chain lay on a textured brown table

How to Keep Sterling Silver Jewelry Looking Brand New

Sterling Silver develops a natural patina over time. It’s not a flaw, it’s part of its charm. That lived-in look adds character and tells a story that’s personal to you. In this article, we’ll brea...

Read more